How does an annual evaluation interview work?

Les points à retenir

Guide to End of Mission and Intercontract Periods

Télécharger la ressource

Discover everything you need to know about the annual review to ensure you support your team as best as possible through these highly important meetings!

What is an annual review?

The annual review, according to some studies, is perceived by 48% of employees as a complicated moment to handle humanely, being particularly stressful. Yet, this meeting is an opportunity for you, managers, and your teams, to take stock and determine new objectives for the next twelve months. 

An annual review is a management practice that allows an employee to exchange directly with their direct supervisor or a representative of the Human Resources (HR) department, in order to take stock of the year that has just passed.

This exchange covers several very different topics, namely: 

  • on work effectiveness, on results observed,
  • on possible areas for improvement expected,
  • on ambition and desires for evolution in the coming months or years,
  • on objectives set for the next year.

Performance Evaluation

Performance evaluation is the main objective of the annual review. 

They allow you to evaluate employee performance, one by one. It is the opportunity for management or HR to verify whether the objectives set at the last meeting were achieved.

It is a good way to congratulate the efforts undertaken, but also and above all to realize certain things that are not working, to then adapt the strategy, according to the observations made and the exchanges carried out.

Setting new objectives

Annual interviews allow management to set new objectives to achieve, whether individual or team-wide, for the coming year.

It is the time to set a course, giving a direction to take that is clear and perfectly understandable.

This is an essential step, because without clear and understandable objectives, your teams may not evolve. And without this sense of growing, of learning, it is turnover that increases.

Skills Development

Beyond management requests, the annual interview is also an opportunity for the employee(s) to assess their own needs.

If they feel they need help or more intensive support on a particular segment, they must have the opportunity to report the information.

Ultimately, this can lead to reflections on the processes in place, on the organization, as well as the implementation of dedicated training to help the employee build skills.

Strengthening communication and team cohesion

The annual interview is also an opportunity for the company to demonstrate that it listens and that the well-being at work of its teams is essential to it. Taking stock means discussing, exchanging, and debating.

It is to demonstrate to colleagues that they are also part of the adventure. Creating a strong company culture based on transparent exchanges is also a good way to retain talent and reduce turnover.

How to prepare an annual review as a manager?

On the manager's side, an annual interview must be prepared in advance. It is indeed imperative to arrive prepared, with all your notes and data, to provide as much value as possible to your interlocutor.

To have a solid foundation on which to build your exchange, you should not hesitate to reread the last annual interview conducted. This allows you to refresh your memory and get a more precise idea of what was highlighted and requested at the time.

It is also important to take the time to prepare feedback to be given, to think carefully about the comments you want to share, so as not to say unnecessary or inappropriate things. Finally, think about the objectives you want to propose to your team member for the year to come. Don't forget to collect feedback from colleagues who work closely with this person. This will enrich your interview and give it more perspective. It's also a good idea to think about the development opportunities you'd like to offer this employee.

How does the interview with an employee unfold?

An annual evaluation interview is conducted in five major phases, even if, ultimately, everything depends on you, the manager, and the habits that are yours.

First step: the assessment and evaluation

The first is the assessment of the past year and the evaluation of performance. Managers, you exchange with your collaborator on what worked well and what worked less well. It's the moment to congratulate the achievements and to speak frankly about the difficulties.

Second step: the expression of expectations and needs

Then comes the moment for your collaborator to express themselves. They can share the difficulties they encountered, their expectations and their future projects. It's their moment to speak up.

Third step: discussion of objectives

The third phase concerns the definition of objectives for the year to come. Based on what has been achieved and the expectations expressed, you jointly define the professional goals that your collaborator will have to achieve over the next 12 months.

Fourth step: discussion of skills development

Next, discuss training, certifications, or skills development opportunities. Assess what learning your collaborator needs to succeed in their role and grow professionally.

Fifth step: summing up and concluding

Finally, summarize the interview, confirm the objectives and expectations, and let your collaborator know what the next steps will be.

And what happens next?

À la fin de l’entretien annuel, un compte-rendu d’évaluation sera rédigé. C’est un document confidentiel, qui doit comporter quelques mentions importantes (pour ne pas dire obligatoire), comme : 

  • la date à laquelle l’entretien individuel a eu lieu,
  • l’identité du manager ou du RH mais aussi celle du collaborateur ainsi que sa position au sein de l’entreprise
  • le récapitulatif du parcours professionnel et des formations éventuellement suivies par le collaborateur interrogé,
  • une synthèse complète des échanges qui ont eu lieu entre vous et votre collaborateur. Il s’agit du “bilan du bilan” en lui-même. Y seront renseignés les observations faites concernant les objectifs, les axes d’amélioration proposés, les besoins exprimés par vos équipes…
  • les nouveaux objectifs que vous avez conjointement fixés,
  • l’ensemble des leviers et actions qui seront mis en place pour y parvenir (formations, responsabilité)
  • autres informations qui seront jugées comme étant importantes.

Ce document, s’il ne doit pas retranscrire mot pour mot tout ce qui s’est dit au cours de l’échange, doit être très complet. C’est lui qui servira de base pour les entretiens annuels d’évaluation qui auront lieu l’année suivante. Il est donc préférable qu’il ne manque d’aucune information importante.

What you need to remember about annual evaluation interviews in business

Côté management, l’entretien annuel nécessite de la préparation. 

Côté collaborateur, c’est la même chose : évaluer ses réussites, faire une introspection pour comprendre ses forces, mais aussi ses faiblesses, exprimer ses ambitions et confier ses craintes… Tout cela nécessite un peu d’anticipation.

Malgré le côté très solennel de la chose, l’entretien annuel d’évaluation reste un moment d’échange et de partage qui vise à permettre aux collaborateurs de repartir avec des informations claires et nettes sur les choses qu’ils font bien, qu’ils maîtrisent et sur celles où quelques lacunes se font ressentir et donc, sur lesquelles ils vont devoir travailler ! 

C’est l’occasion, aussi, de valoriser leur implication, en les félicitant de vive voix pour les efforts entrepris tout au long des douze derniers mois. Cette gratification peut aussi passer par une revalorisation salariale, dont le montant reste sujet à discussion (mais qui oscille généralement autour des 3 à 4%). 

Portrait of a man with short dark hair wearing a grey coat over a white shirt against a dark blue background.

Geoffrey Chapuis

Co-fondateur de Wobee
Geoffrey pilote la vision et la stratégie de Wobee pour transformer les intranets d'entreprise et les parcours RH. Passionné par l'expérience collaborateur et l'innovation technologique.

Améliorez votre expérience salarié avec Wobee !

Prendre rendez-vous !
Email Icon - Techflow X Webflow Template

Inscrivez-vous
à la newsletter

pour ne louper aucune de nos actus

Oups, quelque chose n'a pas fonctionné, veuillez ré-essayer !